This is the fifth essay in Perverse, a series about the good and holy things we’ve bent into something that no longer reflects God. If you’re finding it later, you can read them in any order.
Have you ever been volun-told to do something?
For those who may be unfamiliar with the term, let me explain. It’s the idea of serving volunteering to do something without the option to say, “no.”
Working on a church staff for years, I watched it happen more times than I can count. A ministry needed more hands, so the staff member in charge looked at the people closest to them. Their kids. Their spouse. And so did the rest of the team. No one asked if they wanted to be there, if they were tired, if they were gifted for it, or already stretched thin. They were simply told where to be and what time to show up.
“No,” wasn’t an option.
It’s something I learned the hard way not to do to my own kids or husband. I remember volunteering our daughter to be in a student ministry video where she would have to speak on camera. She made it clear immediately that she didn’t feel comfortable and didn’t want to do it. At the time, just the idea of public speaking created so much anxiety for her. But this wasn’t “live.” Plus, I’d already committed her to it.
She went through with it, including the panic attack right before they started filming. You’d never know if you watched the video. She did great. But I knew what I’d put my daughter through...and I committed to never do that to my family again. Because that’s not what serving should ever look like.
But unfortunately, that’s what it’s become for far too many of us.
I get it. Ministry runs on volunteers, and there are never enough. When you’re responsible for getting a job done at the last minute on a Sunday, the people who live under your roof feel like the easiest solution.
But the longer I watched, the more something sat wrong with me.
That’s not serving.
That’s coercion.
And while most of us have never been volun-told by a staff member, plenty of us have been guilted:
• into signing up when we know we shouldn’t
• into staying on a team long after we we’ve burned out
• into feeling like a disappointment the moment we need a break
Serving is good and holy. Scripture calls us to serve one another. But somewhere along the way, a lot of us stopped serving out of love and started serving out of guilt.
“We get to do this”
If you’ve been in church for a while, you’ve probably heard the phrases. “We get to do this.” “It’s a privilege to serve.” “If everyone would just give one Sunday a month...”
Here’s the tricky part: every one of those is true. It is an honor to serve. But somewhere between the stage announcement and the sign-up sheet, the truth got bent into a lever. “We get to do this” gets said with a smile, but what many of us hear underneath is, “And if you don’t want to, you’re selfish.”
So we sign up. Not because we feel called, but because we feel guilty. The busiest people get praised as the most committed, and the ones who step away quietly wonder if they’re less spiritual. Serving stops being something we offer and starts being something we owe.
I wonder how many of us have served out of guilt for so long that we’ve forgotten what it feels like to serve out of love.
Bodies in slots
I know that guilt firsthand. For years, I felt guilty about not serving in kids’ ministry. Every church I’ve been part of needed more help with children, and I didn’t want to do it. Some people are great with kids. That’s never been me. I love my own desperately. But otherwise, I just don’t connect. So, I never felt led to serve with them. But that didn’t diminish the guilt I felt every time the need was communicated. Especially as a woman, because there’s an assumption that just because you’re a woman, a mother, or a teacher, you would naturally want to serve with children. News flash: we don’t.
And I remember the day everything changed. One Sunday, the pastor said something I’d never heard from a stage. “If you’re not good with kids,” he said, “don’t serve with them. We want you where you’re gifted.”
It’s still one of my favorite moments in church. I’d carried that guilt for so long, and it was never mine to carry. Kids’ ministry wasn’t where God wanted me. Over the years, I’ve served on mission teams and in local outreach. I’ve been a small group leader and served in women’s ministry. I’ve sung on the worship team. I’ve been the cashier in the café.
None of that came from being put where the need was loudest. It came from being invited to serve the way God made me.
Which makes me wonder: do we invite people to serve because it fits their gifting, skills, and God-given wiring? Or do we just put bodies where the need exists?
When serving gets lost
Scripture is clear about how we’re meant to serve. Peter puts it simply: “Each of you should use whatever gift you have received to serve others“ (1 Peter 4:10).
Whatever gift you have received.
Not whatever slot is empty.
You can’t volun-tell someone into love. And you can’t guilt them into it, either. Guilt can fill a schedule. It can’t change a heart. When serving is pressured, guilted, or assigned, it isn’t service anymore. It’s compliance.
And serving shouldn’t be motivated by self-promotion. Sometimes serving is seen as a way to seek approval, validation, or leadership. We volunteer in hopes that someone will notice. And as a result, we’ll be asked to lead. We’ll finally be recognized. We’ll be included. But that’s the exact opposite of what serving should accomplish in us. Serving should grow our compassion and draw us closer to the heart of Jesus. Not send us looking for a bigger platform.
But what did Jesus say?
If anyone had the right to demand to be served, it was Jesus. Instead, on the night before the cross, He got up from dinner and picked up a towel.
John is careful to tell us what Jesus knew before He did it. “Jesus knew that the Father had put all things under his power, and that he had come from God and was returning to God; so he got up from the meal, took off his outer clothing, and wrapped a towel around his waist“ (John 13:3–4).
Jesus knew who He was. He knew where He came from and where He was going. He had nothing to prove, no approval to earn, and no position to climb toward.
He spent His final evening serving, washing the feet of His disciples, including Peter, who would deny Him before morning, and Judas, who had already decided to betray Him.
When He was finished, He said, “I have set you an example that you should do as I have done for you“ (John 13:15). We usually hear that as an assignment. But the example isn’t only what He did. It’s why He did it. He served people He loved, from a heart that already knew it was loved by the Father.
That’s the order guilt gets backward. Guilt says, serve so you’ll be enough. The towel says, you’re already loved, so go love.
Serving has seasons
But the Bible doesn’t tell us to serve until burnout or exhaustion. Even Jesus stepped away. When the crowds pressed in, real people with real needs, Luke tells us He “often withdrew to lonely places and prayed“ (Luke 5:16). He didn’t meet every need in front of Him. He trusted the Father with the rest.
Serving can look different in different seasons. What it looks like with toddlers at home won’t be the same as with an empty nest. A season of grief or burnout might mean stepping back for a while. That isn’t failure. It’s wisdom.
Too often, we commit with our “yes” before we’ve even paused to consider if we should, because we don’t feel like we have permission to say anything else. If that’s you, I want you to know:
It’s okay to not commit right away and pray about it.
It’s okay to set boundaries.
It’s okay to say, “Not right now,” or “That’s not the best fit for me.”
It’s okay to step away from one place so you can serve well in another.
And for those of us who lead: when someone steps back, what if our first response was “thank you” instead of “are you sure?”
Closer than we think
Sometimes we shrink serving down to a Sunday slot or a mission trip. But the people who need to be loved are usually much closer than that. The kids in your child’s classroom. The neighbor whose name you still don’t know. The coworker eating lunch alone in their car. The stranger in the grocery line having the worst day.
Serving doesn’t have to include a registration form. It just asks you to notice.
What if, instead of filling slots, we invited people to see who God has already put in front of them, and to serve the way He wired them? What if serving looked less like an obligation and more like an overflow?
If you’ve been serving out of guilt, hear this: Jesus never needed your obligation. He wants your heart. And He’s not keeping a roster.
Next week, just in time for Thanksgiving weekend, we’ll look at another good thing we’ve bent out of shape: generosity. What happens when our giving starts expecting something in return?
Sit With This
When have you served because you wanted to, and when have you served because you felt guilty? What did each one feel like on the inside?
Where has God wired you to serve? Is there a place you’ve stayed out of guilt that may not be yours to carry?
What season are you in right now? What might it look like to serve from this season, boundaries included, instead of the one you think you should be in?
Keep Reading
This is the fifth essay in Perverse, a series asking how we’ve taken good and holy things and turned them into something that no longer reflects God. Next week: Perverse Generosity. Until then, here are a few more to sit with:
Perverse Perseverance: When does our refusal to quit become an idol? It pairs with Perverse Loyalty and Perverse Surrender, because guilt-driven serving is often where staying too long begins.
The Freedom to Love: What Olivia Dean’s concert reminded me about growing older, following Jesus, and loving our neighbor.
Extending Grace to Who You Were: Our hindsight should bring clarity, not condemnation.
Hi! I’m Torrie. Thanks for stopping by.
If this article encouraged you, provided language for what you’re feeling,
or challenged you, I’d love to hear your story in a comment below.




This feels like a book in the making. Don't stop.